Unraveling the Mysteries: Why Has PayPal (NASDAQ:PYPL) Missed the 2023 Tech-Stock Surge?


In the ever-evolving landscape of tech stocks, one notable absentee from the surging rally of 2023 is PayPal (NASDAQ:PYPL). It’s a conundrum that has left investors scratching their heads. The answer, it appears, lies in the prevailing market sentiment of uncertainty regarding PayPal’s direction during this transitional phase for the company. However, for those willing to embrace a degree of risk, this uncertainty could present an opportune moment to invest in PayPal at an attractive share price.

It’s essential to recognize that PayPal boasts a significant user base, with reportedly 70% of Millennials relying on the platform for their financial transactions. This fintech giant is a formidable player that many in the financial community may be underestimating.

PYPL Stock: A Footing in Turbulent Times:

Uncertainty is the nemesis of financial markets. Paradoxically, it’s during periods of uncertainty that astute investors often find undervalued assets. While some may find it psychologically challenging to navigate uncharted waters, it’s precisely these conditions that can present compelling investment opportunities.

At this juncture, we invite you to lean into the prevailing uncertainty surrounding PayPal, rather than shying away from it. The company is undergoing a pivotal transition, with Alex Chriss poised to assume the role of PayPal CEO, succeeding Dan Schulman on September 27.

Of note, Chriss comes from outside the PayPal executive ranks, a fact that has not gone unnoticed by market observers. As Miles Nadal, the founder of Peerage Capital, points out, “Coming from the outside, whatever your credentials or accomplishments, you are going to face fear-based skepticism.”

However, it’s important to note that PYPL stock’s struggles in 2023 stem from various factors, including concerns over the competitive threat posed by Apple’s Apple Pay service. Nevertheless, it’s reasonable to surmise that the market’s apprehension regarding PayPal is not solely rooted in competitive pressures but also in the impending leadership change.

Seeking Stability Through PayPal’s Stablecoin:

The crux of the matter is affording the incoming CEO an opportunity to chart PayPal’s future course before passing definitive judgment on its prospects. Concurrently, it’s prudent to consider that PayPal is currently trading at what appears to be a reasonably fair valuation, with a trailing 12-month price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio of 17.76x.

A noteworthy development awaiting Chriss’s stewardship is PayPal’s foray into the world of stablecoins with “PayPal USD.” This cryptocurrency token, owing to its stablecoin classification, will be tethered to the value of the U.S. dollar.

The intriguing aspect here is the potential trajectory of PayPal USD under Chriss’s guidance. Even if it doesn’t immediately translate into day-to-day transactions, there’s a strong likelihood that customers will utilize PayPal USD for purchasing and trading other cryptocurrencies on the PayPal platform.

In parallel, the U.S. government continues to grapple with defining its regulatory stance on stablecoins. The prospect of PayPal emerging as a pioneer in a potential stablecoin revolution in the 2020s is undeniably captivating.

Assessing the Risks and Rewards of PYPL Stock:

AB Bernstein analyst Harshita Rawat aptly identifies the CEO transition as a key source of uncertainty that has cast a shadow over PayPal’s stock. However, this uncertainty is not without its silver lining. The market’s wariness is likely to dissipate once the new CEO takes the reins, potentially paving the way for an uptick in confidence.

Crucially, PayPal is spearheading a potentially transformative stablecoin initiative. Viewed in this context, PayPal may well be an undervalued gem, with market apprehension appearing somewhat excessive. Therefore, for those cognizant of the risks involved, this juncture presents an opportune moment to explore PYPL stock with a measured investment position. In the dynamic realm of fintech, PayPal’s future trajectory remains an intriguing narrative worth monitoring closely.


As PayPal charts its course through the turbulent waters of change, investors have the chance to reassess its potential. This is not merely a financial transaction platform; it’s a fintech powerhouse with an enduring user base. Uncertainty may cloud the horizon momentarily, but for those willing to navigate these uncertain waters, the allure of PayPal’s future is difficult to ignore. In the intricate tapestry of tech stocks, PayPal may yet emerge as a story of resurgence and resilience.