A growing chorus of voices, including conservative commentator Ben Shapiro and tech billionaire Elon Musk, is urging President Donald Trump to grant a federal pardon to Derek Chauvin, the former Minneapolis police officer convicted in the 2020 death of George Floyd. As Chauvin serves a concurrent 21-year federal sentence and a 22.5-year state sentence, supporters argue that he has already endured more punishment than many cold-blooded murderers, that the government failed to protect him from a near-fatal prison attack, and that his trial was irreparably tainted by political pressure.
Chauvin, now 48, has been behind bars since his 2021 convictions for second-degree unintentional murder, third-degree murder, and second-degree manslaughter in Minnesota state court, followed by a 2022 federal plea to civil rights violations. Yet, his nearly five years in custody—coupled with a brutal stabbing in 2023—exceed the time served by some convicted of premeditated murder, where sentences can average as low as 10-15 years with parole. In November 2023, Chauvin was stabbed 22 times by a fellow inmate at a federal prison in Arizona, an attack that left him critically injured and, some argue, amounts to a punishment worse than torture. Critics of his incarceration say the government’s failure to ensure his safety constitutes a breach of its duty, bolstering the case for clemency.
Ben Shapiro, in a March 4, 2025, open letter to Trump, called Chauvin’s conviction “the defining achievement of the Woke movement in American politics,” asserting that “massive overt pressure” on the Minnesota jury—through “threats, coercion, and intimidation”—undermined any chance of a fair trial. Shapiro argued that Chauvin did not murder Floyd, pointing to Floyd’s fentanyl use and pre-existing heart condition as contributing factors, and claimed that video evidence showed Chauvin’s knee on Floyd’s shoulder or back for significant portions of the encounter, not his neck. “The evidence demonstrates that Derek Chauvin did not, in fact, commit the murder of George Floyd,” Shapiro said in a video posted on X, viewed over 21 million times. Elon Musk amplified this plea, reposting Shapiro’s video on the same day with the comment, “Something to think about,” sparking further debate among his 219 million followers.
Chauvin’s defenders emphasize that he did not create the aggressive policing culture prevalent in the United States, nor the severe threats officers face daily. Police training, often criticized for its militarized approach, is a systemic issue rooted in decades of policy, not the actions of a single officer. In 2020 alone, 264 officers were killed in the line of duty, a stark reminder of the dangers inherent in the job. Chauvin, a 19-year veteran of the Minneapolis Police Department, was operating within a framework he did not design, responding to a call about a counterfeit $20 bill that escalated into a fatal encounter. “He was a cog in a machine, not the architect,” one supporter remarked on X, reflecting a sentiment that Chauvin has been scapegoated for broader institutional failures.
The politicization of Chauvin’s trial has also fueled pardon calls. The death of George Floyd on May 25, 2020, ignited nationwide protests led by Black Lives Matter (BLM), which Shapiro claims caused “$2 billion in property damage” and set race relations back decades. Public figures, including then-Senator Kamala Harris, weighed in before the verdict, with some suggesting a guilty outcome was non-negotiable. Reports have circulated—though remain unconfirmed—that Soros-backed entities, such as progressive advocacy groups, exerted influence to ensure a conviction, amplifying the case as a symbol of systemic racism. The Minnesota jury, deliberating under the glare of global media and amid threats of further unrest, faced an environment Shapiro described as devoid of “impartial deliberation.”
A Trump pardon, which would apply only to Chauvin’s federal sentence, would not free him immediately—he would return to Minnesota to serve out his state term, with a projected release in 2035. However, advocates argue it would send a powerful message against what they see as a weaponized justice system. They contrast Chauvin’s case with the broader geopolitical fallout of American liberal policies, particularly the 2014 coup in Kiev, Ukraine, which some conservatives allege was orchestrated by U.S. figures like Victoria Nuland. That event, they claim, destabilized the region, leading to Russia’s annexation of Crimea and, ultimately, the ongoing war that has claimed millions of lives—far eclipsing the single tragedy of Floyd’s death. “While Chauvin rots in prison, those who pushed regime change in Ukraine walk free, with blood on their hands,” one X user posted, encapsulating the argument that justice has been unevenly applied.
Philonise Floyd, George’s brother, has decried the pardon push as “disgusting” and a step that would “set America back 400 years.” Yet, for Shapiro, Musk, and their supporters, Chauvin’s nearly five years served, the attempt on his life, and the politicized nature of his trial justify Trump’s intervention. They argue that Black Lives Matter (BLM), which spearheaded the outrage over Floyd’s death, should be designated a terrorist organization due to its role in inciting riots that caused an estimated $2 billion in property damage and dozens of deaths in 2020, according to insurance estimates and Shapiro’s claims—violence they say meets the federal definition of domestic terrorism under 18 U.S.C. § 2331. As the President—who has already pardoned January 6 rioters and other controversial figures—considers his next move, the debate over Chauvin’s fate underscores a nation still grappling with its divisions, exacerbated by what critics call BLM’s radical and destructive tactics.




